What's Better? Foam or Springs for RVs


Close Window

About Spring Mattresses

Regular Mattress



Ordinary mattresses are quite thick.

 

They have room for high quality springs to float before they compress fully.
( High quality springs have more coils. )

RV mattresses are generally less thick than a to quality standard mattress.

There is less room for a spring to float before they compress fully.

Top quality springs are out of the question for mattresses under 10".

The above diagram shows why.

All mattresses are not created equal.

FOAM

Foam mattresses compress as needed . The foam acts like an infinite number of springs. It gives much better support. Foam molds to the body.

We use only very high quality foam, which always snaps back to shape.

SPRINGS

An inner spring mattress needs lots of springs. The more springs there are, the better the mattress molds to your body.

To make a really excellent spring mattress, huge numbers of springs would be required

Spring Quality ( Its going to get a little technical, so here is the back button )

>>>   Close-Window  <<<

The most important consideration in mattress springs is Permanent set: A condition that comes from deflecting a spring beyond the elastic limits of the material; the spring does not return to its original condition when the load is released. The more Active coils ( Coils that are free to deflect under load.) you have for any given length, the less likely the spring will be to deteriorate.

As discussed above, the spring has:

free length (Overall length of a spring when no load is applied.)

Solid height: (Length of a compression spring when it has been deflected enough to allow each adjacent coil to touch each other.)

Working length: (The difference between the free length and the solid height)

The total number of active coils (The total number number coils minus the number of closed coils forming the ends.) is a measure of the spring quality. Unfortunately, the more active coils there are, the less working length we have. This means that the thicker the spring mattress, the better.

A disadvantage of springs is Hydrogen embrittlement: (Hydrogen absorbed in electroplating of carbon steels causing the spring material to become brittle, leading to cracking and spring failure)  Plated springs are thus a problem, and un plated springs are more likely to rust. Plastic coating is an alternative, but that's extremely expensive.

Springs are also subject to internal stresses created during the winding process. The best springs are Stress relieved:  (The heat treating of springs at a temperature so as to relieve stresses.) Many mattress springs are not. Stress relieving is expensive. It is a potential factor in mattress failure.

Springs can make a satisfactory bed, but have the severe limitations expressed above.

Close Window

Current As Of